I wish I had of chose to stay It didn’t have to be this way We knew deep down right from the start That you and I should never part But we don’t have to question why When you look into that night sky We will find each other Starlight First star I see tonight Starlight First star I see tonight I never meant to hurt you, dear Not that you need that to be clear I’m just a shadow of your soul Year after year, I pay the toll But we don’t have to question why When you look into that night sky We will find each other Starlight First star I see tonight Starlight First star I see tonight Starlight First star I see tonight