The stars are out tonight Ever wonder if they are aligned, never know Find out think it's gotta be so Somebody told you a story or two So many whispers that you thought were true, never knew You found out about the worst people do Don't think that this is the same thing, ooh Some of the sting is remaining But that's not me You and I are a story never told (Chorus): Starry eyes, where have you been? All of this time I waited so long Looking for you Starry eyes, I've been dreaming And I'm feeling like it's gonna come true So far yet getting so close We're afraid of what we want the most, and I know 'Cuz you told me what happened before Don't think that this is the same thing, ooh Some of the sting is remaining But that's not me You and I are a story never told (Chorus) Don't think that this is the same thing, ooh Some of the sting is remaining But that's not me You and I are a story never told (Chorus)