You looked surprised that night That night when all the words were right Your friends told me that you were behind the gym The rest of us inside And when you took me by the hand and said That you would never break my heart again I think I told you that I'd never leave I guess that was a lie You look surprised that night That night when all the words were right Your friends told me that you were behind the gym The rest of us inside And when you took me by the hand and said That you would never break my heart again I think I told you that I'd never leave I guess that was a lie You looked surprised that night That night when all the words were right Your friends told me that you were behind the gym The rest of us inside And when you took me by the hand and said That you would never break my heart again I think I told you that I'd never leave I guess that was a lie