[Verse 1] I had to catch my breath When I saw you there across the room Holding her hand I'd have never guessed That starting over would look so good on you But here I am Still believing there might come a day We'll pick up where we left off [Chorus] And by the way Your eyes are dancing I'd say the chances of that are getting slim By the way My heart's still breaking It's going to take it a while to love again So many things that I forgot to say By the way [Verse 2] I should've let you know All the ways you made me feel alive I guess it's too late So I'll just get my coat And make my way into this breezy night Give you one last wave Maybe you'll drop what you're doing And come over here to say I'm looking good [Chorus] But by the way Your eyes are dancing I'd say the chances of that are getting slim By the way My heart's still breaking It's going to take it a while to love again So many things that I forgot to say [Verse 3] By the way You still look amazing And I must've been crazy to let you get away By the way If you ever wondered Still got the same old number; just in case I still miss you And I still love you By the way By the way, oh