The light in her bedroom as she kept the curtain closed The shadow was cast as she was taking off her clothes I stood on the sidewalk and looked up from below Oh, oh, oh Lightning strikes with the blankest stare, oh my god And he answered my prayers, I was tired and confused I had the scr*pes and bruises, but She took a piece of my heart Walking downtown with nowhere to go In the back of the aisle at the video store I got pulled back in by the undertow (Oh-oh oh) Welcome to the bar, turns on the lights You never know what could happen by the end of the night I got swept away when the tide got high Dreaming, dreaming, dreaming of a girl that I used to know Dreaming, dreaming, dreaming of a girl that I used to know A deer in the headlights, face pale as a ghost Tongue-tied, she was dumbstruck and freezing as she froze The shadow walked past just as the door began to close She took a piece of my heart Walking downtown with nowhere to go In the back of the aisle at the video store I got pulled back in by the undertow (Oh-oh oh) Welcome to the bar, turns on the lights You never know what could happen by the end of the night I got swept away when the tide got high Dreaming, dreaming, dreaming of a girl that I used to know Dreaming, dreaming, dreaming of a girl that I used to know Woah, oh oh Guess I'll be moving on Wonder where it all went wrong Walking downtown with nowhere to go In the back of the aisle at the video store I got pulled back in by the undertow (Oh-oh oh) Welcome to the bar, turns on the lights You never know what could happen by the end of the night I got swept away when the tide got high Dreaming, dreaming, dreaming of a girl that I used to know Dreaming, dreaming, dreaming of a girl that I used to know Dreaming, dreaming, dreaming of a girl that I used to know Dreaming, dreaming, dreaming of a girl that I used to know She's just a girl that I used to know