Ask her for the mail back Turn the call back Sleep it off all afternoon Wherever your head's at Find your way back That's an old, familiar tune [Chorus] (Just when you think) You're all rusted and used (You turn around) You're all shiny and new Ought to just accept she's quite complex She leads you on and leaves you bruised She's an old romantic Her shadow's electric Told a tale a time or two [Chorus] (Just when you think) You're all rusted and used (You turn around) You're all shiny and new Shiny and new, yeah "I've got plans for you this time," she said This town's a storybook We'll skip the chapters you've already read Take an ever-extensive deeper look Well Two of us growing older, going nowhere No, the melody's been used But it's oh so clever If love is forever, then I think I could marry you [Chorus] (Just when you think) You're all rusted and used (You turn around) You're all shiny and new (Just when you think) You're all shiny and new (You turn around) You're all shiny and new (Just when you think) You're all shiny and new Shiny and new, yeah