Do you remember that night in your room Where you had broken up and I was there to win you back I did that twice I had it all planned But there's just one thing that I can't understand Why did you have to cheat your way away from me Why didn't you just say something How could you let me think I had another shot at being good enough If you knew you would be gone first thing in the morning You, you've got some explaining to do So I might have pushed you away, that's what you say But I sure didn't push you into taking me back again You didn't have to do that, you could have hurt me in a lot of ways Now what have you got to say? Why did you have to cheat your way away from me Why didn't you just say something How could you let me think I had another shot at being good enough If you knew you would be gone first thing in the morning You can break up with me all you want But just don't rub it in I kinda got it the first time Is all the pain you put me through The reason I'm still singing about you? Just say something How could you let me think I had another shot at being good enough If you knew that you would be gone first thing in the morning Why did you not pick up the phone when I needed to talk to you Why did you not pick up the phone I needed to scream at you Why did you not pick up the phone You've got some explaining to do