Why did you have to be so good When you didn't mean to stay Why did you have to be so good If you were leaving anyway You left impressions on my heart and in my mind Of a love I'd never had You loved me just long enough to make me blind To all the hurt and pain that I had in the past Why did you have to be so good When you didn't mean to stay Why did you have to be so good If you were leaving anyway You make me feel a way I've never felt before You even promised me a dream You were all that I had Ever had and more