I really don't know what to feel My confusion won't let me sleep You say you love me at dawn And then by sunset you're gone Maybe if you gave a reason why I'd be able to sleep at night Haunted by all the memories Of meeting you that September night Of meeting you that September night Of meeting you that September night CHORUS I wish I could take back that September night Go back in our story and do a whole rewrite Where Romeo & Juliet would have never met Since we skipped ahead and went straight to the end I wish I could take back that September night Go back in our story and do a whole rewrite Where Romeo & Juliet would have never met Since we skipped ahead and went straight to the end VERSE 2 I really don't know what to believe When I'm too tired to even dream Of the look you saved for me I don't think I could ever climb over The great wall around your life Where you kept me on the outside With nothing but the memories Of meeting you that September night Of meeting you that September night Of meeting you that September night CHORUS I wish I could take back that September night Go back in our story and do a whole rewrite Where Romeo & Juliet would have never met Since we skipped ahead and went straight to the end I wish I could take back that September night Go back in our story and do a whole rewrite Where Romeo & Juliet would have never met Since we skipped ahead and went straight to the end