[Verse 1]
I swear when I was young
The summers were full and fresh and long
Watching the movies with Andie in Pink
Dreaming of dances bad memories don't blink
I always said you were a different cla**
Blue eyes and a messed up past
For every single promise I reneged
Every stupid word I wish I hadn't said
[Pre-Chorus]
First love is the best love
First love is the dream
First love is a fairy tale
Held tight between you and me
[Chorus]
Do you remember the first time?
(Do you? do you?) remember the first time?
(Do you? do you?) remember the first time?
[Verse 2]
Cherish the past
You told me to keep what we had safe
Make it last
Even though I knew you'd be a million miles away
And as life happened to me
I know it happened to you
I don't have your number now
But I still see you in everything I do
[Pre-Chorus]
[Chorus x2]
[Verse 3]
It was the first time that I failed
First time I lost my head
No heartbreak has ever been as good
I'd rather be hurt by you instead
And at the end of it all
My heart was black and blue
But sometimes late at night
I still ask myself if you
[Chorus x2]
I will try to forget about you [x4]