Baseball Hank Aaron: Curt Simmons
Richie Ashburn: Bob Gibson
Ernie Banks: Sandy Koufax
Buddy Bell: Jim Palmer
Adrian Beltre: Byung-hyun Kim
Johnny Bench: J.R. Richard
Yogi Berra: Alex Kellner
Roy Campanella: Ewell Blackwell
Ron Cey: Kent Tekulve
Coco Crisp: Jason Grimsley, Pedro Martínez, Brandon League, CC Sabathia
Andre Dawson: John Smoltz
Joe DiMaggio: Mel Harder
Jimmie Foxx: Carl Hubbel
Ken Griffey, Jr.: Tony Fossas
Derek Jeter: Roger Clemens, Pedro Martínez, Mike Timlin
Ralph Kiner: Ewell Blackwell
Kenny Lofton: Al Leiter
Mickey Mantle: Dick Radatz
Stan Musial: Curt Simmons
David Ortiz: Pedro Martínez, Mariano Rivera, Mike Mussina, Sonny Gray, Carter Capps
Al Oliver: Woodie Fryman
Mike Piazza: Orlando Hernández
Frank Robinson: Don Drysdale
Pete Rose: Sandy Koufax
Al Rosen: Frank Sullivan
Mike Schmidt: Nolan Ryan, Tom Seaver, Bob Gibson
Joe Sewell: Dutch Leonard
Al Simmons: Johnny Allen
Tris Speaker: Doc White
Darryl Strawberry: Nolan Ryan
Frank Thomas (1951–1966): Don Drysdale
Frank Thomas (1990–2008): Jeff Nelson
Jim Thome: Randy Johnson
Mickey Vernon: Bob Feller
Jim Abbott: George Brett
Grover Cleveland Alexander: Honus Wagner
Bert Blyleven: Cal Ripken, Jr.
David Cone: Tony Gwynn
Bob Feller: Tommy Henrich
Whitey Ford: Nellie Fox
Doc Gooden: Chili Davis
Lefty Grove: Joe Sewell
Catfish Hunter: Tony Oliva
Jim Kaat: Al Kaline
Sandy Koufax: Hank Aaron
Pedro Martínez: Barry Bonds, Edgar Martínez, Derek Jeter, Kenny Lofton, Ichiro
Jim Palmer: Rod Carew
Gaylord Perry: Billy Williams
Fritz Peterson: Al Kaline
Mariano Rivera: Edgar Martínez
John Smoltz: Tony Gwynn
Curt Schilling: Mark Lemke, Delino DeShields, Lance Berkman, Todd Helton
Mike Scott: Tony Gwynn Basketball Kareem Abdul-Jabbar: (to defend) Bob McAdoo; (to be defended by) Nate Thurmond
Shane Battier (to defend): Kobe Bryant
Bruce Bowen (to defend): Michael Jordan
Bill Bradley (to defend): John Havlicek
Kobe Bryant: (to be defended by) Tony Allen; ("top five players") Hakeem Olajuwon, Michael Jordan, LeBron James, Kevin Durant, Clyde Drexler
Walt Frazier (to defend): Earl Monroe
Horace Grant (to defend): Kevin McHale
Tim Hardaway (to defend): Kevin Johnson
Grant Hill (to defend): Kobe Bryant
Allen Iverson: (to defend) Baron Davis; (to be defended by) Marcus Banks
Nazr Mohammed (to defend): Shaquille O'Neal, Rasheed Wallace, Dirk Nowitzki, Yao Ming, Tim Duncan, Kevin Garnett
Earl Monroe (to defend): Oscar Robertson, Nate Archibald
Dikembe Mutombo (to defend): Hakeem Olajuwon
Shaquille O'Neal (to be defended by): Charles Barkley, Charles Oakley, Karl Malone, Rick Mahorn
Gary Payton (to defend): John Stockton
Paul Pierce (to defend): Kobe Bryant, Tracy McGrady, Vince Carter, LeBron James, Carmelo Anthony
Nate Thurmond (to defend): Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
Jerry West (to defend): Oscar Robertson
Lenny Wilkens (to defend): Oscar Robertson, Jerry West American Football Fred Biletnikoff: Jim Marsalis
Al Toon: Albert Lewis
Champ Bailey : Marvin Harrison
Ronde Barber: Steve Smith, Sr.
Ike Taylor: Steve Smith, Sr., Randy Moss, Eric Moulds
Charles Woodson : Marvin Harrison Soccer David Beckham: Roberto Carlos
Paolo Maldini: Diego Maradona, Ronaldo, Zinedine Zidane
Ronaldinho: Paolo Maldini
Ronaldo: Paolo Maldini
Jamie Carragher: Thierry Henry Hockey