Verse 1: (SING-SING) Last night I had a crazy dream I dreamed of you and me But what's really crazy We used to be reality Thought you felt safe within my arms Never afraid, never alarmed Little did I know that the same comfort Would open up an old scar Chorus: She was an Indian giver Surely had me thinking I was with her She gave her heart to me Before I knew it she took her heart from me Why did she do it? She was afraid from a love past She was scared that she was falling too fast She was an Indian giver Lord knows I'm trying to forgive her for what she did to me Verse 2: (MR. JONES) Why would you lead me on that way Made me believe you're here to stay I had started to lose it But you renewed my faith in love again But baby two wrongs don't make a right And cause he did you wrong I paid the price Because he didn't like you, you strung me along And now I'm part of the cycle Chorus Bridge: And now I have a heavy heart My loves been torn apart Why did she leave me all alone Sitting here in this sorrow, here today gone tomorrow Thanks for letting me borrow your love But I wish I never met ya. Chorus